Our statement, Monday 2 November 2026
Residents took on Cambridge Council and Christ’s College in High Court, and won.
“On Tuesday 20 October 2026 the High Court quashed Christ’s College’s planning permission on all four grounds we brought. The judge recorded ‘errors of approach on each of the grounds’. This is not a procedural footnote. It is a High Court record that the Council got it wrong on every ground, and the Council had accepted as much in writing in April. A community of residents, with no solicitor, took on Cambridge City Council and Christ’s College, the Interested Party, each with their full planning and legal teams, and won. It was David against Goliath, and David won.
The Council misled councillors about Historic England’s advice by leaving out its finding of harm. Historic England found the building ‘too big for its location’ and ‘overdominant on this space’, with harm to the College’s own Grade I listed buildings, and urged that the massing be reduced. It has not been. That finding is the case we have made from the start. The Council also gave councillors confused and contradictory advice on the harm to a Grade I listed library. It told them the scheme would secure the ‘optimum viable use’ of the listed buildings, a benefit national policy gives for bringing a vacant or underused listed building back into use, when the College’s buildings were already in use. And it kept from councillors the possibility that the harm could be avoided through an alternative scheme.
The issues at stake are of significant national interest, and the Council continues to err in its handling of them. Thirteen days before the hearing, the same Council, on the same officers’ advice, approved the identical scheme again on a report that repeats its errors and introduces new errors, told there was ‘no good reason’ to wait for the Court. Its own officers found the scheme in conflict with the Council’s own heritage policy and recommended approval anyway. The Council asked the Court to look at that report, and the Court declined. No court has examined it. There is no confidence that local planning processes are fit to decide this complex and controversial case in a rigorous, fair and lawful way.
The Master of Christ’s College calls that second process exemplary, and says that ‘the fact that a small group of residents does not like the outcome does not invalidate it’. No residents’ group invalidated the first approval. The High Court did, on every ground. Christ’s Lane Action Group is a community of about 300 Cambridge residents. The Victorian Society, a statutory consultee in the planning system, and Cambridge Past, Present and Future, Cambridge’s largest civic society, objected to this building, as did members of the public from across Cambridge and beyond. The College’s support is its own. Of the representations in its favour on the Council’s register, more than two thirds come from the College’s Fellows, staff, students and former students, the Master’s Lodge among them. The small base in this dispute is the College’s.
The Master has also put to the Government, in the House of Lords, the question on which his College’s development turns: should the Secretary of State call in an application that councillors have voted to approve? He tabled it on 19 October, the day before the hearing, withdrew it, and tabled it again on 20 October, the day the Court quashed his College’s permission, declaring his interest each time. In twelve years and more than a hundred thousand questions, only three peers have asked about calling in a planning application while declaring an interest, and only one of them holds a paid post as Master of the applicant. We do not allege a breach of the Lords Code. We ask whether a question put, as a peer, to the very department deciding his own College’s case, in the weeks of that decision, is in the public interest.
The question for Christ’s College is why it pressed for a decision on the identical scheme before the Court had ruled. The same scheme is now frozen by the Secretary of State while she decides whether to call it in, and we have asked her to call it in and decide it herself after a public inquiry, with the evidence tested in the open and all stakeholders, including local residents, taking part. A College that has just lost in the High Court should reflect on the judgment, instead of attacking the residents who won it.
We are not against a new library. We are against this one, which Historic England said is ‘too big for its location’ and ‘overdominant on this space’. If the College truly believes the Council’s decision was not flawed, it should say so to the Secretary of State and accept a public inquiry, where that decision can be tested in the open by an inspector with no interest to declare.”
The High Court has quashed the first permission for the Christ’s College library on all four grounds of our claim.
Mr Justice Kolinsky made the order on Tuesday 20 October 2026, in R (Christ’s Lane Action Group) v Cambridge City Council, AC-2025-LON-004656, in the Planning Court.
The official transcript of the oral judgment will appear here.
On 13 October 2026, six days after Cambridge councillors voted the identical scheme, 26/02109/FUL, through, Angela Rayner, Secretary of State, froze the Christ’s College library permission.
Read the holding direction from the SoS How 13 October went, hour by hour: our newsletter of 14 October To hear from us, email residents@christs-lane.com
The High Court has quashed the Council’s first permission of 7 November 2025 on all four grounds of our claim. On 7 October 2026 the Committee voted to approve the same building again. On 13 October the Secretary of State froze it.
On Tuesday 20 October 2026 the High Court quashed the Christ’s College library permission 25/02161/FUL of 7 November 2025 on all four grounds of our judicial review, R (Christ’s Lane Action Group) v Cambridge City Council, Christ’s College Cambridge interested party, AC-2025-LON-004656. The College had filed the same building again on 10 June 2026 as application 26/02109/FUL. On 7 October 2026 the Council’s Planning Committee approved it, thirteen days before the High Court hearing. On 13 October the Secretary of State directed the Council not to grant permission without her authorisation while she decides whether to call the application in. The direction has no end date.
Stay with us
The Secretary of State is deciding whether to call application 26/02109/FUL in. We need you to write to her in support of a call in. If you would like to, write to us at residents@christs-lane.com and we will tell you how. Read the direction.
Email residents@christs-lane.com to join our mailing list.
Share the Cambridge Independent report with friends.
Join the mailing list Read the report
What we are asking for. We support a new Christ’s College Library. We oppose this design. The benefits to the public are small. The harm to the city’s heritage is not.
The building the Council’s own file says is too big
Christ’s Lane is one of Cambridge’s oldest pedestrian routes; a narrow passage, barely six metres wide, that has carried the city’s foot traffic for centuries, today linking the historic core to the bus station and the Grafton. On one side stands the Grade I listed Bodley Library, Victorian, human-scaled, its perfectly proportioned gable, oriel window and crenelated staircase turret currently visible against clear sky from along the lane.
Christ’s College wants to build a library so large that the experts who reviewed it found it caused heritage harm: a four-storey building whose chimneys stand “approximately 14.2 metres” above the lane, on the case officer’s own figure to the Committee on 7 October, along that same six metres of width, its façade largely blank, looming over the Bodley and turning its back on the town. Planning officers once warned that buildings of such dimensions would turn Christ’s Lane into a “canyon-like, oppressive passageway.”
Every building that has stood here has deferred to the Bodley beside it. This one would not.
Historic England found the building too big for its location
Historic England, the statutory consultee on the historic environment, wrote on 29 July 2025 (register document 9457102): “we are of the view that the building is too big for its location.” It wrote that “The building feels too big, overdominant on this space, particularly in its relationship with the south range of first court and the Bodley Library”, and that the proposals “would result in certain levels of harm to the significance of the listed building, primarily as a result of the excessive bulk of the new building”. It wrote that the proposals “would be bulkier that those that were previously granted consent”. On 8 July 2026 it wrote that its views “remain unchanged from those previously assessed”, and on 27 August 2026 that “We are comfortable that our existing advice remains relevant and appropriate”.
The Council’s own report of 28 September 2026 measures the change at paragraph 16.32: the building beside the lane is “notably increased from approximately 5.7 metres currently to approximately 13 metres”.
The Council’s advice was to step the building away, and the applicants chose to proceed
The Council’s own advice to the College of 19 December 2024 said: “The proposal is higher and larger in scale than the consented schemes, and the proposed scale and massing of this raises concern.” It said: “The proposed building should be stepped away from the Bodley Library and inwards from Christ’s Lane.” The Council’s Amendment Sheet of 5 October 2026 records what followed: “The applicant was given advice to mitigate/ avoid harm to the Bodley Library during pre-application discussions. The applicants have chosen to proceed with the scheme in front of members.”
The Council’s file records the harm, the advice to avoid it, and the choice not to. That is the building the Committee approved on 7 October.
The Christ’s College library permission is frozen.
Six days after Cambridge councillors voted the identical scheme, 26/02109/FUL, through, the Secretary of State stopped the permission being issued. Angela Rayner directed the Council not to grant permission without her specific authorisation, while she decides whether to call the application in. Officers cannot sign it. The Committee cannot sign it. The direction has no end date.
On Tuesday 20 October 2026 the High Court quashed the first permission, 25/02161/FUL, on all four grounds of our claim.
Read the holding direction from the SoS How 13 October went, hour by hour (PDF)
A former Savills head of planning: why it should have been refused
A “fire escape” with no fire strategy. The report says the applicant “has chosen to retain the current height of the proposed staircase tower as an alternative means of escape forming part of the fire strategy” (paragraph 16.34), and the Amendment Sheet rewrote paragraph 26.7 to say the tower “therefore has a minimum height requirement”. The public file holds no fire strategy. Alec Forshaw, 5 October 2026: “No document on the register states a fire requirement for the height of the tower, and no regulation imposes one.” A choice is presented to members as a requirement.
A lower library was approved. Twice. The Council approved lower library schemes here in 2013 and 2016. The 2016 report found: “The proposed new library would meet the needs of Christ’s College”, and at paragraph 8.20, “The various floor levels of the new library provide all the necessary requirements of the College.” The 2026 report gives that design “very limited weight” because “The applicant has made the case that this previous scheme is no longer viable for the College” (paragraph 16.57). Whether the College wants a design is not whether the harm can be avoided.
Historic England: “too big”. The report: “lower end”. Historic England said the building is “too big for its location” and gave no degree of harm. The report as published told members at paragraph 1.25: “As considered by Historic England and the Council’s Conservation officer the proposed replacement library would result in harm (at the lower end of the scale)”, and at 16.38 that the officer’s view “is consistent with that of both Historic England and the Council’s Conservation Officer”. After hgh Consulting’s letter the Council amended 1.25 on 5 October “to clarify that the level of harm is an assessment of the officer and not Historic England” and 16.38 “to remove reference to Historic England’s agreement”. The figure Historic England never gave stayed in the report.
Towering over a Grade I library. On the applicant’s drawing 004700 P03 the parapet stands at 22830 and the Bodley Library gable at 20840: about two metres above a Grade I building. The Local Plan’s Policy 60 applies to “Any proposal for a structure that breaks the existing skyline and/or is significantly taller than the surrounding built form”. The report declares it “not engaged”, and the report’s own words record the frontage rising “from approximately 5.7 metres currently to approximately 13 metres” (16.32).
37 of 61 windows lose their light. On the applicant’s own daylight report, 37 of the 61 windows on the two lower floors opposite fail the daylight test, 35 of them shop windows. eb7, the daylight consultants, found on 5 October 2026 that the four windows of one retail unit’s main frontage and entrance (windows 7 to 10) lose 55, 75, 87 and 96 per cent of their light, and that “Twenty-six windows experience reductions exceeding 50% against the 20% guideline, four of them exceeding 90%.” The report answers at 22.16: “It is therefore not considered to be reasonable to apply the BRE guidelines”, because shoppers “are likely to only visit for a short period of time before leaving”.
The use the College already has, counted as a benefit again. In the High Court the Council conceded that it was an error to weigh improved library facilities as securing the optimum viable use of College buildings that have been in that use for five centuries. The 2026 report repeats the error: it keeps the consideration inside its “lower end” figure for the harm (paragraph 16.39) and moves it into the social benefits: paragraph 26.25 counts “improved, accessible library facilities” as helping “to support and sustain the ongoing use of the Grade I listed College buildings”, and 26.26 gives that group “significant weight”. The Council’s skeleton argument tells the Court that the report “does not rely upon the proposal helping to secure” the optimum viable use of any listed building.
Roger Hepher, former head of planning at Savills. He warned that approval would be “walking inevitably into another - and entirely foreseeable and avoidable – legal challenge”. He urged refusal, or at least a delay until the High Court has ruled.
Read Roger Hepher’s objection (PDF) Read the eight criticisms (PDF)
The latest, date by date
- 2 November 2026Our statement after the Master of Christ’s College’s words in Varsity. Varsity’s report of Friday 30 October 2026 carried statements by the Master about this group as fact, without contacting us for comment before publication. Our statement in reply opens this site and is on the Campaign Statements page.
- 25 October 2026Our newsletter: has the Master of Christ’s College made proper use of his position in the House of Lords? The dates of his two questions, how rarely a peer asks about calling in a planning application while declaring an interest, and the question we put. Open the PDF.
- 23 October 2026The sealed order issues. The Court’s order of 20 October 2026, sealed by the Planning Court on 23 October, names the parties and quashes the permission on each of the four grounds. We sent it the same day to the Planning Casework Unit, which is considering whether to call the application in, and to the press.
- 21 October 2026The national press reports the judgment. The Telegraph, The Independent and the Daily Mail report the High Court fight over the Christ’s College library. The Cambridge Independent: "High Court judge agrees Cambridge City Council got it wrong over Christ’s College library plan". Cambridge News: "High Court finds council ‘wrong’ in library planning battle".
- Quashed · 20 October 2026The High Court quashes the first permission for the Christ's College library on all four grounds. Mr Justice Kolinsky set aside, on our application, the Court's order of 25 August 2026, which had approved a draft consent order we had not signed. The Court quashed the Council's permission of 7 November 2025 (25/02161/FUL) on each of the four grounds of our claim.
- 20 October 2026The Master of Christ’s College tables a question in the House of Lords on calling in planning applications. On 19 October, the day before the hearing, Lord McDonald of Salford tabled a written question asking in what circumstances the Secretary of State should call in an application that councillors have voted to approve, declaring his interest, and withdrew it. On 20 October, the day the Court quashed his College’s permission, he tabled it again. It is due for answer by 3 November 2026.
- Breaking · 13 October 2026Angela Rayner, Secretary of State, freezes the Christ's College library permission. Six days after councillors voted the identical scheme, 26/02109/FUL, through, the Secretary of State directed the Council not to grant permission without her specific authorisation, while she decides whether to call the application in. At 9.22 am we had asked her for a holding direction under article 31, and for the application to be called in. Daniel Zeichner, Member of Parliament for Cambridge, forwarded our submission the same day. At 8.37 pm her Planning Casework Unit replied that a direction had been issued that day which "prevents the Council from granting planning permission without special authorisation". The direction is on the Council's register as document 9554694: "the Secretary of State hereby directs your Council not to grant permission on this application without specific authorisation." The Unit has confirmed to us in writing that it "has no end date". Read the direction, the Council's acknowledgement and the Unit's letters.
- 15 October 2026Our emails to city councillors no longer pass through the Council's mailbox. The Council's Single Point of Contact wrote to us on Thursday 15 October that, with immediate effect, direct emails to City Councillors would no longer pass through the mailbox. Since August every email we sent to the Council had been blocked and went instead to that mailbox. Our letter of 30 September to the fourteen members of the Planning Committee never reached them from us. It reached them at 4.44 pm on Friday 2 October as a different email from the mailbox, under the mailbox's own subject line, with our text pasted below a note. The change came eight days after the vote.
- 14 October 2026The national press reports the freeze. The Architects' Journal: "Rayner intervenes to halt Grafton's controversial Cambridge library". Building Design: "Rayner freezes consent for Grafton's Cambridge library six days before scheme heads to High Court". The story led Building Design's daily news email of Wednesday 14 October 2026, first in the subject line and first under "Latest news".
Four grounds on the basis of which the High Court quashed the first permission on Tuesday 20 October 2026
- 1
Historic England found harm. The report told members that, in line with comments received from Historic England, there was no overall harm. Historic England wrote on 29 July 2025 that "the building is too big for its location" and that the proposals would cause harm "primarily as a result of the excessive bulk of the new building". The report's conclusion at 14.33 told members: "In line with comments received from Historic England and the Council's Conservation officer, who raise no objection to the development, the development is not considered to result in any overall harm to the relevant heritage assets, applying paragraph 215 of the NPPF". Our claim: "This was factually incorrect, and positively misleading." The ground: "The Committee was materially misled as to Historic England's advice."
- 2
The report found harm to the Grade I listed Bodley Library and told members, in the same paragraph, that the overall impact was neutral. At 14.31 the report found "a level of harm identified to the highly significant Grade I listed Bodley Library" and concluded: "The overall impact upon the relevant listed buildings is therefore considered to be neutral". At the meeting the officer said "the overall harm is considered to be neutral" and, in the same answer, "because there is harm identified, public benefits need to be provided". Our claim: "These two conclusions are logically inconsistent." The ground: "The Committee was materially misled as to the existence and/or extent of harm to the significance of designated heritage assets."
- 3
Members were told the library would "help to secure the listed building's optimum viable use". The listed buildings have been in that use for five centuries; the Council conceded this was an error. "Optimum viable use" is a term of the heritage guidance for a listed building whose upkeep depends on finding a use that pays for it; securing such a use is a public benefit that can be weighed against harm. The 2025 report told members at 14.19 that the library "would help to secure the ongoing use of the listed buildings for their intended, educational use" and at 14.31 that it "would help to secure the listed building's optimum viable use". Our claim: "There can be no question that the optimum viable use of the listed buildings as an educational institution is already secured". The ground: "The Committee took into account an irrelevant consideration - optimum viable use ('OVU')."
- 4
The Council had twice consented a lower library on this site. Members were told to assess the scheme "on its own merits" and were never asked whether the lower design would avoid the harm. The Council granted permission for Rick Mather Architects' design, with a basement, in 2013 and 2016, and its report of 2016 found: "The proposed new library would meet the needs of Christ's College". The 2025 report "said nothing whatsoever about the 2011/2016 schemes, whether in the context of OVU or generally" (our claim, paragraph 81); the officer's amendment sheet for that meeting told members "the current proposal must be assessed on its own merits". The ground: "The Committee failed to take into account a relevant consideration – the existence of less harmful alternative modes of development."
Errors repeated.
Before the High Court could rule on errors in the first application 25/02161/FUL, the College resubmitted an identical building application 26/02109/FUL, repeating errors and introducing new errors. These errors, and what members were told on 7 October, are set out on The application page.
The timeline
- 07 Nov 2025Council grants planning permission
- 18 Dec 2025Judicial review claim filed in the High Court on four grounds
- 06 Mar 2026Mr Justice Kimblin grants permission on all four grounds, finding them “strongly arguable”
- 10 Jun 2026Second application 26/02109/FUL submitted: errors unfixed, harm called benefit
- 29 Jul 2026Development Control Forum: 75 petitioners put their case to councillors at the Guildhall
- 25 Sep 2026We send the Council our case against the report before it is written: the letter to the case officer naming the findings the report must make, the harm register, Historic England's own casework file on how the harm could be avoided, the five lower or distributed designs, and the letters to the conservation, environmental health and sustainability officers
- 29 Sep 2026Sir Peter Lane keeps the hearing of 20 October listed; the Council and the College had asked whether it could be vacated
- 01 Oct 2026Those papers appear on the register, backdated to 25 September
- 05 Oct 2026The Amendment Sheet, its file generated at 6.49 pm, is published on Monday evening, two days before the Committee
- 07 Oct 2026Identical application 26/02109/FUL controversially approved, thirteen days before the hearing
- 13 Oct 2026Secretary of State directs the Council not to grant permission without her authorisation while she considers call in
- 20 Oct 2026The High Court quashes the first permission, 25/02161/FUL, on all four grounds
Judicial Review: The Record
The court documents recording the challenge, the grant of permission, the signed draft order and the listed hearing are below.
In the College’s Own Words
While the first application was still before the High Court, the College resubmitted the same building as application 26/02109/FUL, with errors repeated, and the bulk the experts call heritage harm presented as a heritage benefit.
Here’s the sting. The building may be unchanged… but so are the errors. Historic England called the building “too big” and “overdominant” : heritage harm the College is legally required to offset with public benefits. The College brands that same bulk as a heritage benefit, telling councillors and the public that “the need to apply public benefits to outweigh heritage harms does not… apply here.” Call “harm” a “benefit” and the public is owed nothing in return.
The Bursar wrote to all 42 councillors assuring them the application was unchanged, and did not mention the draft consent order the College had signed weeks earlier agreeing that its permission should be quashed. And when 75 residents petitioned for the public Forum they are entitled to, the College refused to attend it. Below, the pitch in the College’s own words: the covering statement, the Bursar’s email, the refused request for a public Forum, and the College’s own open meeting.
An organised group of residents took the College and the Council to the High Court, both signed a draft order agreeing that the permission be quashed on all four heritage grounds, and the College’s answer is to double down on its errors.
The public is robbed.
Holding the College and the Council to Account
Cambridge’s planning safeguards are meant to catch errors before a decision is made. On the Christ’s College library they have failed repeatedly, and each time it was residents, not the Council, who found the failure and forced its correction.
In July 2026 CLAG put that pattern to the Council twice. On 16 July, at Public Questions to Full Council, CLAG asked the one question the Council has not answered: with the High Court due to hear the case on 20 October, will the Council agree an extension so the second application, 26/02109/FUL, is not decided first?
On 29 July, at the Development Control Forum that 75 petitioners secured, CLAG put the College’s own masterplan to councillors as the live, less harmful alternative.
On 7 October 2026 the Planning Committee approved the identical scheme, 26/02109/FUL, thirteen days before the hearing. On 13 October the Secretary of State directed the Council not to grant permission without her specific authorisation. The records are below.
Heritage Harm
Read it in the experts’ own words. Historic England, the Victorian Society, Cambridge Past, Present & Future and conservation specialist Alec Forshaw each weighed the scheme against its Grade I listed setting, and each reached the same verdict: a building too large for its surroundings, causing real harm to Cambridge’s most sensitive heritage assets.
Read what the four heritage assessors found
Daylight & Sunlight
The applicant’s own daylight and sunlight report contradicts the claim that Christ’s Lane would not be overshadowed. Although the applicant’s shading study shows only limited times and angles "favourable to the applicant," eb7’s independent review for CLAG finds it already shows "darker shadows cast across the lane at 6pm on the summer solstice." On the applicant’s own figures, eb7 wrote on 5 October 2026: “Thirty-six windows serving the retail units and coffee shops fall below the BRE targets.” “Twenty-six windows experience reductions exceeding 50% against the 20% guideline, four of them exceeding 90%.” The Council’s report never names Policy P3 of the new Framework, which gives the shops and cafés on the lane a right to “adequate access to light”, and no shadow study of the lane has ever been submitted.
The claims, set beside the documents
Our case rests on primary sources, not assertion. The College’s JR Claims Fact Check sets four of the College’s public statements beside the court orders, consultation responses and its own papers they refer to. Every quotation is verbatim, with the original document linked. And after CLAG fact-checked The Observer’s 5 July 2026 column, The Observer corrected its article online ; the corrected paragraph and the correction note are reprinted on the page.
Alternatives
The College’s bulky scheme was never the only option. The law requires that heritage harm be avoided where a lower or distributed design can do the job, and five are on the record. The College’s own design of 2013 and 2016 by Rick Mather, with a basement, won planning consent twice; the Council found in 2016 that it “would meet the needs of Christ’s College”. The Create Streets variant of that consented design, commissioned by CLAG, keeps the same lower envelope under a contemporary facade. The Victorian Society specified in writing on 22 August 2025 a library on this site scaled to the Bodley Library’s floors, “reducing the height by approximately half at each floor”. The College’s own masterplan, adopted by its Governing Body in October 2023 and drawn by MICA Architects, names five study and library places, so that a lower library here can be joined by study space in rooms the College already holds. And the Hobson Street library, the masterplan’s own third study and library place, was the second of the “two possible sites for the library” the College’s architects put to the Governing Body. Each of the five would place less bulk on this site than this building. The College’s needs met, the heritage harm avoided, the lane left intact.
Campaign Posters
The campaign in its own voice. The posters and flyers below are how residents first told Cambridge what was at stake on Christ’s Lane, plain, public and impossible to miss.
Press: "controversial", in the papers' own words
The Architects' Journal, 14 October 2026: "Rayner intervenes to halt Grafton's controversial Cambridge library". Building Design, 13 October 2026: "Grafton Architects' controversial Cambridge college approved for the second time". Building, 13 October 2026: "Controversial Cambridge college approved for second time". Planning, 15 October 2026: "a university college's controversial plan to redevelop a library building". The Cambridge Independent, 8 October 2026: "Controversial Christ's College library plan approved by Cambridge City Council ahead of High Court hearing".
The Architects' Journal took the dispute national on 29 July 2026, under "Planning row erupts over Grafton's Cambridge library job", and its report of the Secretary of State's intervention stood first under "Most popular" on its site three days after it was published. The story led Building Design's daily news email of Wednesday 14 October 2026, first in the subject line and first under "Latest news".
- "Rayner intervenes to halt Grafton's controversial Cambridge library""Housing secretary Angela Rayner has called an 11th-hour halt to controversial plans for a new Grafton Architects-designed library at Cambridge University amid a looming High Court showdown". First under "Most popular" on the Journal's site on 17 October.
- "Rayner issues holding direction to halt councils' approval of university library rebuild"The direction prevents two councils "from granting final permission for a university college's controversial plan to redevelop a library building".
- "Christ's College library plans halted while secretary of state considers call‑in""A government intervention has stopped Cambridge City Council from issuing a decision notice on Christ's College's controversial new library plans."
- "Grafton Architects' controversial Cambridge college approved for the second time""Grafton Architects' plans for a new library at Christ's College, Cambridge have been approved for the second time following a row with local campaigners."
- "Controversial Cambridge college approved for second time"The same report.
- "Controversial Christ's College library plan approved by Cambridge City Council ahead of High Court hearing""Christ's College's controversial plans for a new library have been approved for a second time by Cambridge City Council, despite a warning from opponents that it is "walking inevitably" into an "avoidable legal challenge"."
- "Forum to discuss Grafton Architects' controversial Cambridge library plans ends in recrimination""A forum intended to bring dialogue between a Cambridge college and opponents of its new library proposals ended in recrimination this week."
- "Planning row erupts over Grafton's Cambridge library job"The scheme "has become embroiled in a major planning row"; "Late last year Cambridge City Council's planning committee voted four to two in favour of the controversial application."
Cambridge objected, on the record
Residents, traders, chartered engineers, planners and conservation professionals all put their names on the record against this scheme. Heritage bodies called it harmful. Here is a glimpse of what they said.
“something out of Mordor” a designer who has worked in Cambridge and London
“more like a tunnel than a lane” a lifelong Cambridge resident
“a private scheme in a public space” a design professional with a Cambridge studio
The Christ’s College Library+ scheme: the questions people are asking
The short answers are below. For the full story, Historic England, the Victorian Society, the chimneys, the alternative designs and the economic toll on the Lane, read the complete FAQ.
Why did residents take Christ’s College to the High Court, and what happened?
Residents challenged the Council’s grant of planning permission by judicial review. The High Court granted permission on all four grounds. On Tuesday 20 October 2026 the High Court quashed the permission, 25/02161/FUL, on all four grounds of our claim. The case number is AC-2025-LON-004656.
Did Christ’s College resubmit the same scheme after the court ruling?
Yes. While the first application was still before the High Court, the College resubmitted the same scheme as application 26/02109/FUL. The Bursar told all 42 councillors the application is unchanged, but omitted to mention that the College had just agreed that the first permission should be quashed.
What was Historic England’s warning about the Christ’s College Library+ scheme?
Historic England found the new building “too big for its location” and “too large for what is a very domestic setting,” causing harm through its “excessive bulk.” Under planning law such heritage harm must be justified by public benefits, yet the College recasts that same bulk as the benefit, so the public is left owed nothing in return.
What happened on 7 October 2026, and since?
Identical application controversially approved on 7 October (26/02109/FUL). On 13 October the Secretary of State directed the Council not to grant permission without her specific authorisation while she considers whether to call the application in. No permission has been issued. On 20 October 2026 the High Court quashed the first approval, 25/02161/FUL, on all four grounds of our claim.
The first permission is quashed. The second is frozen.
On Tuesday 20 October 2026 the High Court quashed the first approval, 25/02161/FUL, on all four grounds of our claim. The Secretary of State has frozen the permission. On 13 October she directed the Council not to grant it without her authorisation while she considers whether to call the application in, six days after the identical application 26/02109/FUL was controversially approved. If you would like to support a call in, write to us and we will tell you how.
Email residents@christs-lane.com.


